What makes a romance story engaging, and what mistakes should writers avoid?
Share
Sign Up to our social questions and Answers Engine to ask questions, answer people’s questions, and connect with other people.
Login to our social questions & Answers Engine to ask questions answer people’s questions & connect with other people.
Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
What makes a romance story engaging, and what mistakes should writers avoid?
Ooh, love this question (pun slightly intended 😄). Romance stories hit different when they feel real and make you care about the characters. Here’s what makes a romance story actually engaging:
What makes a romance story engaging:
Chemistry that sizzles – Not just physical attraction, but witty banter, emotional connection, tension, and moments where you feel why they’re drawn to each other.
Flawed but lovable characters – Nobody wants perfect people falling in love. Give us characters with baggage, quirks, fears—and let us see them grow.
Slow burn or earned love – Instant love is fine sometimes, but what really pulls readers in is the journey. The little moments, the miscommunications, the “oh no I’m falling for them” beats.
Conflict that makes sense – Not drama just for the sake of it. The best conflicts stem from deep character differences or fears that make the relationship feel risky.
Emotional payoff – Whether it’s a happily ever after or a bittersweet ending, we want to feel like everything they went through was worth it.
Mistakes writers should avoid:
Forcing the romance – If two characters have no spark, no connection, and are just shoved together because “it’s a romance,” readers can tell.
Toxic behavior romanticized – Love shouldn’t mean control, manipulation, or emotional abuse. Unless it’s being critiqued or unpacked in the story, it’s a no.
Unrealistic communication issues – Misunderstandings are fine, but don’t stretch them out for 100 pages when one normal conversation could fix it.
Flat side characters – The main couple shouldn’t exist in a vacuum. Friends, family, exes—they all make the love story feel more real.
Lack of stakes – If there’s nothing at risk emotionally, professionally, or personally, it’s hard to care if they end up together.
At the end of the day, a romance story works when it makes readers feel—but not through clichés or shortcuts. Just give us real people, messy love, and a story that makes us root for them.
That sucks when someone says stuff like that—it’s never fun. But honestly, how you respond depends on the vibe you want to keep. Here are a few ways you can handle it, depending on your mood and the situation:
1. Stay Cool and Confident
Just smile and say something like:
“Cool story.” or “Everyone’s entitled to their opinion.”
That shows you’re unbothered, and it kind of takes the power away from their words.
2. Flip It with Humor
Sometimes joking back lightens the mood and shows you don’t take them seriously:
“Guess I’m winning at losing, then.”
“Ignorant? I prefer ‘selectively informed’.”
3. Call It Out (If You Feel Like It)
If it’s someone you actually care about or deal with often, you can say:
“Hey, that was kind of harsh. What’s up with that?”
It can open a real conversation instead of just a back-and-forth insult thing.
4. Ignore and Walk Away
If they’re not worth your time, don’t give them your energy. Not everything needs a response.
Silence hits hard sometimes.
5. Protect Your Peace
If it’s constant or starts affecting how you feel about yourself, it’s okay to create some distance or talk to someone you trust. You don’t have to deal with that kind of negativity on your own.